How Should Couples Merge Their Accounts?

by A Blinkin on July 31, 2012

Last weekend, Miss Blinkin and I began the process of merging our finances. After mentioning the merger on the blog, I received a suggestion from The Blue Collar Workman.

You should definitely share how exactly you two Blinkins are combining acounts, etc. Whose money is paying for what? Do you get allowances or take what you need? Whose bank? etc. It would be awfully interesting to hear how you do it and how it goes!

Just about everything I do can be described as “awful” or “interesting” so I think I can do this.

Before we discuss account management, let’s take a step back and cover something more general: Money. 

How Should Couples Discuss Money?

Since I’ve been engaged for all of 1 month, I’m clearly qualified to dish out some advice.

Money is a touchy subject. A lot of people prefer not to talk about it. Why? Because most people don’t have as much of it as they lead on. If they are open about their finances then they will incidentally reveal their mistakes.

When have you ever heard someone describe their ideal hunk as “tall, dark, and broke?”

Never.

But that doesn’t mean you can’t be in a relationship. Fear not, money isn’t everything. What is more important is honesty. If you are struggling financially, tell your significant other. You don’t have to use the word “struggling.” Instead frame it with something like: “Hey babe, I accidentally killed a guy a few years back and didn’t tell anyone. No, I’m only kidding. But on a serious note, my bank account is kinda low.”

Honesty is the best policy.

What happens when you’re not open about your finances?

Example:

Girl meets guy. Guy doesn’t have a lot of money. Girl expects fancy dinners. Guy can’t afford fancy dinners. Guy has two choices:

a) Pretend to have more money than he does. Eat fancy dinners. Gets into worse financial position. Stress causes guy to get angry. Girl dumps guy.

b) Don’t eat fancy dinners but blame it on “not wanting to go out.” Girl dumps guy.

If you’re not honest about your situation with the person that is supposed to be closest to you, you have no chance at having a meaningful relationship.

Ramit Sethi has some great advice around how to introduce money into your relationship.

Bring the topic up lightly. “Hey, I’ve been trying to learn about money lately…What do you think about investing versus saving?” If you don’t get an answer, try this: “Okay, hey, I have another question…What do you think about my spending? Is there anything you think I should change?” I guarantee you they’ll have an opinion on that – and although you’re sacrificing yourself, at least it’ll get the conversation started. Visit Ramit’s site for more information.

So you all have had the money conversation, now how do you go about merging accounts?

How Should Couples Merge Their Accounts?

One thing I’ll always stress is that personal finance is personal. What makes sense to me may not make sense to you. You should constantly compare the alternatives to ensure you’re making the best decisions possible. I know a lot of people that will set up 100 different accounts depending on the purpose for the money – which is fine – because it makes sense to them. I, however, prefer simplicity.

So I am opting to close my accounts (except my credit cards and my business account) and add my names to her accounts. One reason I chose this solution is for simplicity. I want to keep the number of companies I do business with to a minimum. Also, I chose this solution because closing my accounts requires action.

I have had automatic drafts from my checking account for a long time. I’m a huge fan of the automation because it ensures that I will save and my bills will be paid. But sometimes automation can be a bad thing.

I have watched roughly $80 disappear from my checking account each month simply because I’m lazy. A Netlix subscription and my gym membership. Neither of which I have taken full advantage of. The need to close my account forces me to discontinue these drafts.

We’re going with the simple setup of 1 checking, 1 savings, and a joint credit card. We will put $4000 into the checking account ($1000 each biweekly) and the remainder into the savings account. We expect to live off of 1/3 of our income and save the rest.

We are both smart spenders and solid savers so, thankfully, there are no difficult conversations to be had.

Readers: Do you prefer to keep your accounts separate? Do you talk about money with your significant other?

 

  • http://www.moneylifeandmore.com/ Lance@MoneyLife&More

    My girlfriend and I have separate accounts until we eventually get married when we plan to combine accounts. We do often talk about our spending and financial position though so there won’t be any surprises thankfully!

    • Funancials

      It’s funny because I would recommend 99% of couples to keep things separate. I have seen too many horror stories come from couples combining finances too soon.

  • http://www.debtsntaxes.com/ DebtsnTaxes

    The wife and I have separate accounts for four years now. They are separate but combined I guess because we are both on eachothers accounts and have access anytime to each account. We kept it like that because we have certain bills like student loans that come out of one account and something else comes out of the other. I guess laziness is the reason why we still haven’t combined completely. It’s not a trust issue or anything like that because we both have the same beliefs and goals for our money. All of the debts should be paid off in December and I think we will finally combine everything then. It would sure make it easier to keep track of.

    • Funancials

      That seems like a good time to merge the accounts. I have a few questions for you:
      1. Have you ever been charged a fee on one account that you wouldn’t have incurred if the accounts were combined?
      2. Were they initially kept separate because of the mindset – I don’t want to pay for your student loans and you shouldn’t pay for mine? It was debt that you all had before you got together?

      • http://www.debtsntaxes.com/ DebtsnTaxes

        Nope, no fees have ever been charged to either account. We did go over on one checking account one time because we forgot to transfer money but our credit union has overdraft protection and they give you one freebie a year so no fee was charged.

        As for your second question, we have never had that mindset. We were dating when I was deployed overseas back in 05′ and before I left she was added to my account and she paid all my bills while I was gone. On my blog I have always stated that the student loans are our student loans when in all reality they are hers because mine were paid for by the military. We have always thought of debt as our debt. No matter whos account it was under or if the debt was from before we were married we just made sure the bills were paid. So all but the first year of dating we have been on eachothers accounts. Just not completely combined yet.

  • http://www.bluecollarworkman.com/ TB at BlueCollarWorkman

    I think the fact that you’re both smart spenders and savers will really help you guys out. It sounds like you two are on teh same page which will probably keep money arguments at a minimum. I’m a fan of simple too, man, so combining accts like that seems like a nice idea.

    Hey thanks for featuring my comment, I’ve never had that happen before! :-)

    • Funancials

      It helps that our views align. Neither of us have $300,000 in credit card debt – that would probably change things.

  • http://www.myjourneytomillions.com Evan@MyJourneytoMillions

    We do it up a little differently and it really worked well for us:

    http://www.myjourneytomillions.com/articles/my-familys-cash-flow-chart/

    May work out for you 2

    • Funancials

      Believe it or not, I remember reading this article when it originally went live. Lots of thought. We’ll have some similarities in ours but all coming from checking.

  • http://www.aaronhung.com/ Aaron Hung

    It’s always good that you spouse is on the same page as you in regards to spending and saving. It takes a whole lot of stress away. My wife and I just pour money into one account to pay for everything and it’s been working for us.

    • Funancials

      I know you used to be a banker, right? How did that affect the choices you all made?

  • http://erinshanendoah.com/lifebypets/ shanendoah

    C and I combined accounts before we were even engaged. Bought a car together, too, so we are perhaps not the best role models for smart couples’ money management, but combined accounts really work for us. One of the reasons is that it requires us to talk about money. I may manage the spreadsheets, but C has a debit card and a credit card. He can spend money if he wants, so we both have to know where we’re at financially. And since we both have different strengths (and weaknesses) when it comes to money, we’re both benefiting.

  • Pingback: When Most Couples Fight About Money, Apologies Aren’t An Option! | Financial Conflict Coach

  • Pingback: For the Love of Feet -- A Blue Collar Roundup | Blue Collar Workman

  • Pingback: Financial Articles this Week from Finance Blogs | Personal Investment Management and Financial Planning

  • Pingback: Nerdy Finance #7

  • Pingback: The Carnival of Financial Camaraderie #46 | Finance Product Reviews - Be Informed

  • Pingback: Financial Carnival for Young Adults – 26th Edition - 20s Finances

  • Pingback: Canadian Personal Finance Happy Hour – 10th edition – What to buy? | Canadian Personal Finance

  • Pingback: Yakezie Carnival, Dog Days of Summer Edition » Frugal Portland

  • Pingback: Carnival of Retirement – Tips and Topics For Your Golden Years | Saving to Inve$t

  • Pingback: Good Week, Drive-in Theaters and a Carnival - Wealth Artisan

  • Pingback: Festival of Frugality #350 |

  • Pingback: Weekly Shout Outs: Couples Edition

  • Shannon_ReadyForZero

    Thanks for sharing your story! It’s so hard to find couples finance tips so it’s really great that you share yours here. I’ve included a link to this in ReadyForZero’s Weekly Shout Outs: Couples Edition so our readers can enjoy this great advice as well. (http://blog.readyforzero.com/weekly-shout-outs-couples-edition/)

Previous post:

Next post: