Are You A Mental Accountant? (Grand Finale)

Post image for Are You A Mental Accountant? (Grand Finale)

by A Blinkin on January 23, 2012

Remember when Jeff Foxworthy came out with his unforgettable series, “You Might Be A Redneck?” It was a huge hit that led to book deals, TV shows, and enough riches to fund every redneck’s retirement. The only problem with the series was that (although funny) it wasn’t very educational – at least not compared to Are You Smarter Than A 5th Grader. After seeing how my visitors have spiked the past few days, I’m hoping my “Are You A Mental Accountant” series will follow in Foxworthy’s footsteps.

To Recap

You might be a mental accountant if…

  • You have savings in the bank AND carry balances on your credit cards.
  • You spend “gift” money differently than you would spend money from your savings account.
  • You treat your tax refund differently than your usual paycheck.

The Solution

What kind of person would I be if I put all my efforts into pointing out what is wrong with you but didn’t offer solutions to help?

Answer: an ex-girlfriend.

  • Treat all money as earned income.

Anytime you receive a windfall, regardless of how much it is, pretend it is money earned from your primary job. Don’t think you can do that? Then try thinking about how much time it would take you to earn the amount you’re about to spend. Maybe this will slow down your spending.

  • Chill out on your credit card.

Don’t take this the wrong way. I love my credit card. I use it for everything. Rewards programs are too lucrative right now to use cash. However, if you’re spending more money than you normally would because of the convenience of plastic, then you’re doing yourself more harm than good.

  • Break down your major purchases.

Don’t group purchases together. If you’re buying a car for $20,000, don’t tack on the sunroof for $1000 and the heated seats for $1000 simply because you’re already spending $20,000. Instead look at each purchase individually. If you’ve been driving your car for 2 years, would you pay $1000 for those same heated seats?

  • Slow your roll.

There’s no deadline on when you have to spend money. If you receive a windfall, before making any sudden moves – wait a few months.

  • Make your weakness your strength.

If you have a problem with mental accounting then use it to your advantage. If you are mentally setting up separate accounts for different purposes then do just that. Set up multiple accounts with automatic drafts from your paycheck to fund them.

Conclusion

Don’t think I’m some sort of genius for presenting the concept of mental accounting. Just remember, I read and regurgitate. If you want a more in-depth look into mental accounting, I recommend you read How Smart People Make Big Money Mistakes.

Thanks for reading,

A. Blinkin

  • Paul Weaver

    I work at a bank, and can’t tell you how often I see people waste away their tax returns, bonus, or inheritance. It’s important to reiterate the basics, sometimes people forget.

    http://makemoneymakecents.com

    • Anonymous

      I’ve worked at a bank before as well and have witnessed the same thing. What was frustrating was watching someone come in with a refund of $9000 and I know they didn’t have $9000 of earned income. Hmmm…I would just tell them “you’re welcome.”

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NNQTITGQC3L7GHWAKXTTBRIDVA Rachel

    I started working on my tax return this weekend, and I can’t tell you how many times I had to stop myself from planning some kind of crazy splurge purchase. Right now the plan is to pay for my tags and pay off 2 of my credit accounts and put the rest into a savings account. The urge to spend like it’s going out of style is ridiculous. Also need to adjust my withholding, but that’s a totally different topic all together.

    • Anonymous

      Proud of you :)

  • http://www.dollarversity.com Eric J. Nisall – DollarVersity

    I find that slowing my roll sometimes makes me walk away from a purchase completely. Of course, I also happen to be a very picky shopper to begin with in all regards. But, if I give myself some time to think about things, I usually end up talking myself right out of the purchase completely, which isn’t too hard to begin with. Case in point: my hesitance to buy a tablet even though it would benefit me greatly.

    • Anonymous

      I can be odd when it comes to spending. Smaller purchases on “wants” I will take forever to make the purchase; and like you said, I’ll typically not even make the purchase. The only thing I’m bad about spending on is food. I’m a sucker for fancy meals.

      • http://www.dollarversity.com Eric J. Nisall – DollarVersity

        I’m a big foodie too. Not so much fancy meals, as I don’t think Capital Grille or Ruths Chris are anywhere near as good as what the costs are, but I’ll spend money readily on really good food!

        • Anonymous

          I will say Ruths Chris has an executive special to go for $20. You have to order it at the bar or to go. Steak, side, and salad.

        • Anonymous

          I will say Ruths Chris has an executive special to go for $20. You have to order it at the bar or to go. Steak, side, and salad.

  • http://www.worldoffinance.biz/ World of Finance

    Apparently, not enough people got the memo on mental accounting lol. Thanks for sharing A. Blinkin

  • http://www.worldoffinance.biz/ World of Finance

    Apparently, not enough people got the memo on mental accounting lol. Thanks for sharing A. Blinkin

  • http://superfrugalette.com/ Super Frugalette

    I am not a mental accountant…I am the polar opposite

  • http://www.americandebtproject.com/ American Debt Project

    I need all of these tips…I’ve done all of the bad things at some point! But “mental accountant” sounds like a good term to me…or are you saying mental as in crazy?

  • Pingback: Planning and Personal Investment Articles this Week | Personal Investment Management and Financial Planning

  • Pingback: Yakezie Carnival - The Superbowl Clones Game | Steadfast Finances

  • Pingback: My Blog » Blog Archive » Yakezie Carnival – The Superbowl Clones Game | Steadfast Finances

  • Pingback: Entrepreneurship Advice » Blog Archive » Yakezie Carnival – The Superbowl Clones Game | Steadfast Finances

  • Pingback: Totally Money Carnival – Super Bowl Edition - 20's Finances | 20's Finances

  • Pingback: Carnival of Wealth, Ronald Reagan's 101st Birthday Edition | Control Your Cash: Making Money Make Sense

  • Pingback: A blog about newlyweds managing finances in relationships. | Newlyweds on a Budget

  • Pingback: Carnival of Retirement 5th Edition » Financial Success for Young Adults

Previous post:

Next post: